The Progressive Corporation · PGR · FY2026 Q2 · Calendar Q3 2026

Progressive highlights property turnaround and disciplined expansion

The supplied analysis supports a constructive but conditional view of Progressive's growth setup: management paired a completed property turnaround with opportunities in personal auto, bundled products, distribution, and AI-enabled efficiency. The case depends on sustaining underwriting performance, executing the capital plan, and containing catastrophe, competition, and regulatory risks.

Reported Before market openNYSEFinancial Services $120.31B market cap
100quality score

Earnings scorecard

Reported versus consensus
Reported EPS $4.85 Consensus $4.64
EPS surprise +4.5% Reported versus consensus
Reported revenue $21.08B Consensus $19.49B
Revenue surprise +8.2% Reported versus consensus

Market reaction

prior-close to event-session close
Stock move -9.4% Event window
SPY move +0.4% Same window
Abnormal move -9.8% Stock minus SPY
Volume 2.0× Versus trailing sessions
Subsequent drift +1.0% Up to 20 sessions
PGRSPY benchmark

Ask FN2 about PGR FY2026 Q2

Transcript, numbers and history already loaded

Free account. Your question opens in FN2 with this report's transcript and numbers attached.

Transcript intelligence

What changed

Relative to the prior-quarter analysis, the current call placed greater emphasis on the completed property turnaround, the Robinson bundled opportunity, broader property availability, targeted rate reductions, and a formalized AI strategy council. The prior analysis had emphasized strong underwriting, capital efficiency, and new product horizons; the current analysis shifted toward scaling distribution and applying those capabilities to growth.

Guidance delta

No formal guidance was provided in the supplied current-quarter analysis. Management emphasized continued expansion, selected rate reductions, AI initiatives, and progress toward the stated capital target.

Key takeaways

  • Management described the property turnaround as substantially complete, with profitability emphasized as the foundation for further expansion.
  • The growth plan centers on broader property availability, new product models, targeted rate actions, advertising, and agency distribution.
  • Management identified the Robinson bundled segment as a significant opportunity across direct and agency channels.
  • AI remains a strategic priority, with a dedicated council and multiple initiatives focused on pricing, underwriting, loss ratios, and expenses.
  • The call retained a confident tone while highlighting competition, catastrophe exposure, regulatory change, and execution risk.

Management priorities

  • Expand property products into additional states and lower-risk markets.
  • Use data-driven pricing, underwriting, and AI initiatives to improve efficiency and loss performance.
  • Broaden distribution through HomeQuote Explorer, agency partners, and targeted agent programs.
  • Pursue the 3.5:1 premium-to-surplus target while continuing dividends and share repurchases.

Follow PGR with an agent that reads every filing, transcript, and price print. Free to start.

Try FN2 free

Earnings History

Estimate Beat Miss Match
PGR EPS earnings history estimate and actual scatter chart 9 reported fiscal quarters and 4 future estimate-only quarters. Q1 '24 estimate $3.21 Q1 '24 actual $3.73, beat Q2 '24 estimate $2.01 Q2 '24 actual $2.65, beat Q3 '24 estimate $3.69 Q3 '24 actual $3.58, miss Q2 '25 estimate $4.43 Q2 '25 actual $4.88, beat Q3 '25 estimate $4.99 Q3 '25 actual $4.05, miss Q4 '25 estimate $4.44 Q4 '25 actual $4.67, beat Q1 '26 estimate $4.85 Q1 '26 actual $4.81, miss Q2 '26 estimate $4.64 Q2 '26 actual $4.85, beat Q3 '26 estimate $4.13 Q4 '26 estimate $4.08 Q1 '27 estimate $4.40 Q2 '27 estimate $3.91
Show 1 more >

Analyst Consensus ?

ConsensusHold42 ratings
Bullish1638.1%
Neutral2252.4%
Bearish49.5%

Analyst 52W Price Targets

$206.94Current
$85Low
$213.79Average
$309High

Latest persisted target per named analyst; persisted current price from FN2's market snapshot as of Sep 23, 2026. Not an FN2 forecast.

Firm-level rating actions

FMP grade actions identify the grading firm, not a named analyst.

FirmRatingPrior ratingActionDate
Keefe, Bruyette & Woods Outperform OutperformMaintainSep 18, 2026
Mizuho Neutral NeutralMaintainSep 16, 2026
UBS Neutral NeutralMaintainAug 27, 2026
Wells Fargo Underweight UnderweightMaintainAug 20, 2026
Cantor Fitzgerald Neutral NeutralMaintainAug 17, 2026
JP Morgan Neutral NeutralMaintainAug 4, 2026
Morgan Stanley Equal Weight UnderweightUpgradeJul 24, 2026
Evercore ISI Group In Line In LineMaintainJul 16, 2026
BMO Capital Market Perform Market PerformMaintainJul 16, 2026
B of A Securities Buy BuyMaintainJul 16, 2026
HSBC Hold HoldMaintainJul 6, 2026
Jefferies Hold HoldMaintainMar 24, 2026
Citigroup Buy BuyMaintainFeb 4, 2026
Barclays Overweight Equal WeightUpgradeJan 8, 2026
Goldman Sachs Buy BuyMaintainOct 28, 2025
Raymond James Outperform OutperformMaintainOct 17, 2025
Roth MKM Buy BuyMaintainFeb 25, 2025
TD Cowen Hold HoldMaintainNov 8, 2024
Piper Sandler Overweight OverweightMaintainAug 15, 2024
Credit Suisse Neutral NeutralMaintainAug 18, 2022
MKM Partners Buy BuyMaintainJul 18, 2022
Edward Jones Hold BuyDowngradeFeb 9, 2022
Wolfe Research Underperform UnderperformMaintainAug 17, 2021
Deutsche Bank Buy BuyMaintainFeb 1, 2021
B. Riley Securities Neutral BuyDowngradeMar 11, 2020
B. Riley FBR Neutral BuyDowngradeMar 11, 2020
B. Riley Neutral BuyDowngradeMar 11, 2020
Buckingham Research Neutral NeutralMaintainDec 6, 2019
Buckingham Neutral NeutralMaintainDec 6, 2019
Keefe Bruyette & Woods Market Perform OutperformDowngradeMay 17, 2018
Sandler O'Neill Buy HoldUpgradeMar 21, 2017
Bank of America Buy NeutralUpgradeMar 20, 2017
Bernstein Market Perform OutperformDowngradeJan 19, 2016
Sterne Agee CRT Neutral NeutralMaintainSep 21, 2015
JMP Securities Outperform Market OutperformMaintainSep 16, 2015
Janney Montgomery Scott Buy NeutralUpgradeJan 7, 2015
Janney Capital Buy NeutralUpgradeJan 7, 2015
Evercore Partners Equal Weight UnderweightUpgradeJul 15, 2014
William Blair Outperform UnderperformUpgradeMar 21, 2014
Nomura Reduce ReduceMaintainDec 12, 2013
RBC Capital Sector Perform OutperformDowngradeMar 14, 2013
Macquarie Underperform NeutralDowngradeJan 17, 2013
Show less

Named analyst price targets

Upside is calculated against the persisted current price $206.94. FMP does not supply a rating on these named-analyst rows.

FirmAnalyst52W targetPrice when postedUpsideDate
Raymond JamesGregory Peters$245$213.48 +18.4%Sep 21, 2026
Mizuho SecuritiesYaron Kinar$230$221.31 +11.1%Sep 16, 2026
UBSBrian Meredith$234$222.51 +13.1%Aug 27, 2026
Roth CapitalHarry Fong$245$217.27 +18.4%Aug 20, 2026
Goldman SachsAlex Scott$230$216.15 +11.1%Aug 19, 2026
JefferiesAndrew Andersen$228$216.03 +10.2%Aug 19, 2026
Cantor FitzgeraldRyan Tunis$200$207.7 -3.4%Aug 17, 2026
Mizuho SecuritiesAnalyst unavailable$236$210.75 +14.0%Aug 5, 2026
Morgan StanleyBob Huang$210$207.07 +1.5%Jul 24, 2026
BMO CapitalAnalyst unavailable$205$205.22 -0.9%Jul 16, 2026
Wells FargoElyse Greenspan$198$205.22 -4.3%Jul 16, 2026
Evercore ISIAnalyst unavailable$240$229.64 +16.0%Jul 10, 2026
Mizuho SecuritiesAnalyst unavailable$243$232.9 +17.4%Jul 9, 2026
HSBCVikram Gandhi$221$232.22 +6.8%Jul 6, 2026
UBSAnalyst unavailable$230$220.17 +11.1%Jun 30, 2026
Wells FargoAnalyst unavailable$205$224.34 -0.9%Jun 29, 2026
Wells FargoElyse Greenspan$219$204.42 +5.8%Jun 18, 2026
RBC CapitalAnalyst unavailable$208$197.89 +0.5%May 22, 2026
BMO CapitalMichael Zaremski$220$201.92 +6.3%May 20, 2026
BMO CapitalAnalyst unavailable$221$201.23 +6.8%Apr 16, 2026
Wells FargoElyse Greenspan$218$201.23 +5.3%Apr 16, 2026
BarclaysAlex Scott$247$202.79 +19.4%Mar 18, 2026
BMO CapitalMichael Zaremski$208$203.21 +0.5%Mar 11, 2026
Piper SandlerPaul Newsome$259$212.8 +25.2%Mar 2, 2026
Goldman SachsAlex Scott$225$203.69 +8.7%Feb 23, 2026
UBSBrian Meredith$218$203.62 +5.3%Feb 23, 2026
Evercore ISIAnalyst unavailable$230$203.52 +11.1%Feb 19, 2026
Roth CapitalAnalyst unavailable$235$203.32 +13.6%Feb 19, 2026
Wells FargoAnalyst unavailable$214$203.28 +3.4%Feb 19, 2026
JefferiesAnalyst unavailable$216$209.29 +4.4%Feb 11, 2026
UBSAnalyst unavailable$226$208 +9.2%Feb 2, 2026
BMO CapitalAnalyst unavailable$232$208.88 +12.1%Jan 29, 2026
HSBCAnalyst unavailable$224$201.97 +8.2%Jan 16, 2026
BMO CapitalMichael Zaremski$239$205.5 +15.5%Jan 15, 2026
Mizuho SecuritiesYaron Kinar$240$205.83 +16.0%Jan 14, 2026
Wells FargoAnalyst unavailable$240$216.5 +16.0%Jan 13, 2026
BarclaysAlex Scott$265$209.1 +28.1%Jan 8, 2026
Goldman SachsAnalyst unavailable$227$209.1 +9.7%Jan 7, 2026
Evercore ISIAnalyst unavailable$237$213.98 +14.5%Jan 7, 2026
Wells FargoElyse Greenspan$242$224.86 +16.9%Dec 19, 2025
BMO CapitalAnalyst unavailable$253$227.27 +22.3%Dec 18, 2025
Mizuho SecuritiesAnalyst unavailable$242$236.18 +16.9%Dec 15, 2025
BMO CapitalAnalyst unavailable$256$223.16 +23.7%Dec 9, 2025
BMO CapitalMichael Zaremski$260$226 +25.6%Nov 21, 2025
Wells FargoAnalyst unavailable$247$222.93 +19.4%Nov 20, 2025
HSBCVikram Gandhi$259$225.14 +25.2%Nov 17, 2025
JefferiesAndrew Andersen$232$223.15 +12.1%Nov 14, 2025
Goldman SachsAlex Scott$245$216.64 +18.4%Oct 27, 2025
BarclaysAlex Scott$257$225.61 +24.2%Oct 20, 2025
Morgan StanleyBob Huang$214$225.61 +3.4%Oct 20, 2025
Raymond JamesAnalyst unavailable$265$223.34 +28.1%Oct 17, 2025
BMO CapitalAnalyst unavailable$247$226.5 +19.4%Oct 16, 2025
Wells FargoElyse Greenspan$246$226.5 +18.9%Oct 16, 2025
UBSAnalyst unavailable$261$244.82 +26.1%Oct 8, 2025
BarclaysAnalyst unavailable$271$243.89 +31.0%Oct 8, 2025
Evercore ISIAnalyst unavailable$273$247.51 +31.9%Oct 1, 2025
BMO CapitalAnalyst unavailable$252$243.49 +21.8%Sep 18, 2025
Wells FargoAnalyst unavailable$265$243.49 +28.1%Sep 18, 2025
BMO CapitalAnalyst unavailable$250$243.61 +20.8%Sep 17, 2025
Morgan StanleyAnalyst unavailable$267$249.21 +29.0%Aug 22, 2025
Morgan StanleyBob Huang$265$246.51 +28.1%Aug 11, 2025
Morgan StanleyBob Huang$330$288.24 +59.5%May 19, 2025
Wells FargoElyse Greenspan$328$283.66 +58.5%May 7, 2025
Goldman SachsAlex Scott$294$246.74 +42.1%Nov 6, 2024
BMO CapitalMichael Zaremski$273$241.48 +31.9%Nov 4, 2024
Goldman SachsAlex Scott$292$250.74 +41.1%Oct 21, 2024
Morgan StanleyBob Huang$310$251.34 +49.8%Oct 18, 2024
CFRACatherine Seifert$290$252.61 +40.1%Oct 16, 2024
Wells FargoElyse Greenspan$297$251.6 +43.5%Oct 16, 2024
CitigroupMichael Ward$257$255.36 +24.2%Oct 4, 2024
Goldman SachsAlex Scott$280$255.44 +35.3%Sep 17, 2024
Morgan StanleyBob Huang$300$255.46 +45.0%Sep 16, 2024
Bank of America SecuritiesJoshua Shanker$309$255.46 +49.3%Sep 15, 2024
Morgan StanleyBob Huang$260$255.46 +25.6%Sep 14, 2024
Wells FargoElyse Greenspan$282$251.31 +36.3%Sep 10, 2024
BarclaysAlex Scott$267$253.91 +29.0%Sep 4, 2024
Bank of America SecuritiesJoshua Shanker$312$252.2 +50.8%Sep 3, 2024
Piper SandlerPaul Newsome$252$234.34 +21.8%Aug 15, 2024
Goldman SachsAlex Scott$262$235.17 +26.6%Aug 15, 2024
Evercore ISIDavid Motemaden$257$234.34 +24.2%Aug 14, 2024
HSBCVikram Gandhi$253$222.99 +22.3%Aug 12, 2024
BMO CapitalMichael Zaremski$237$214.05 +14.5%Aug 7, 2024
JefferiesYaron Kinar$257$210 +24.2%Jul 17, 2024
Morgan StanleyBob Huang$255$212.53 +23.2%Jun 10, 2024
Wells FargoElyse Greenspan$243$209.22 +17.4%May 20, 2024
BMO CapitalMichael Zaremski$235$209.25 +13.6%May 16, 2024
CFRACatherine Seifert$235$206.59 +13.6%Apr 15, 2024
BMO CapitalMichael Zaremski$234$206.85 +13.1%Apr 15, 2024
JefferiesYaron Kinar$245$203.9 +18.4%Apr 12, 2024
Piper SandlerPaul Newsome$240$202.26 +16.0%Apr 12, 2024
Morgan StanleyBob Huang$247$206.15 +19.4%Apr 11, 2024
Evercore ISIDavid Motemaden$215$204.88 +3.9%Mar 15, 2024
Morgan StanleyBob Huang$227$196.01 +9.7%Mar 6, 2024
Raymond JamesGregory Peters$165$157.41 -20.3%Oct 16, 2023
CitigroupAnalyst unavailable$111$137.45 -46.4%Feb 1, 2023
BarclaysAnalyst unavailable$109$126.58 -47.3%Dec 15, 2022
Raymond JamesGregory Peters$140$125.16 -32.3%Aug 29, 2022
Morgan StanleyAnalyst unavailable$130$127.48 -37.2%Aug 19, 2022
BarclaysAnalyst unavailable$106$127.29 -48.8%Aug 18, 2022
MKM PartnersAnalyst unavailable$135$113.16 -34.8%Jul 18, 2022
Morgan StanleyAnalyst unavailable$121$112.9 -41.5%Jul 18, 2022
Credit SuisseAndrew Kligerman$124$106.95 -40.1%Apr 28, 2022
JefferiesYaron Kinar$90$108.72 -56.5%Jan 30, 2022
Evercore ISIDavid Motemaden$118$109.75 -43.0%Jan 14, 2022
MKM PartnersHarry Fong$115$101.33 -44.4%Dec 16, 2021
KBWMeyer Shields$92$101.33 -55.5%Dec 16, 2021
Morgan StanleyMichael Phillips CFA$85$94.61 -58.9%Jun 7, 2021
Piper SandlerNicole Miller Regan$96$94.65 -53.6%Apr 12, 2021
Show less

Track every rating change on PGR the moment it posts. Free to start.

Start free

Company context

Snapshot as of publication

The Progressive Corporation, an insurance holding company, offers a comprehensive range of insurance products and associated services across the United States. Its portfolio includes personal and commercial vehicle coverage, residential and commercial property protection, general liability, and various other specialized property-casualty insurance options. The company's operations are structured into three main divisions: Personal Lines, Commercial Lines, and Property. Within the Personal Lines segment, Progressive provides coverage for individual automobiles and recreational vehicles. Offerings range from standard personal auto policies to specialized options for motorcycles, all-terrain vehicles (ATVs), RVs, watercraft, snowmobiles, and similar forms of personal transport. The Commercial Lines division focuses on providing primary liability and physical damage insurance for business vehicles, alongside general liability and property insurance tailored for commercial applications.…

Historical context

All PGR earnings

Financial Services peers this season

Latest reports in the same sector

Latest beats and misses

Who reports next

Get the PGR recap when the next report posts

One email per quarter with the scorecard, the market reaction and what changed on the call. No account needed.

Sources

  1. Earnings call transcript and parsed analysis · 2026-08-04T17:13:01.315339+00:00
  2. FN2 earnings calendar · 2026-08-20T01:23:16.878803+00:00
  3. Polygon adjusted daily market bars · 2026-09-23T03:50:58.176668+00:00
  4. Financial Modeling Prep analyst price-target consensus and quote snapshot · 2026-09-23T03:50:58.173841+00:00

Methodology

Reported and consensus figures come from FN2's earnings event records. Market reaction and volume are calculated from daily adjusted bars around the event; abnormal move subtracts the SPY move over the same window.

Analyst target low, average, and high values are derived at request time from each named analyst's latest persisted FMP target. The current-price marker comes from FN2's persisted market snapshot. They are sell-side estimates, not an FN2 valuation or recommendation.

Transcript intelligence is a structured synthesis of the current and prior earnings-call analyses. Missing values stay missing and are never estimated.

By FN2 Research · Updated · As of 2026-09-23. For educational purposes only; not investment advice.