American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG · FY2025 Q1 · Calendar Q2 2025

AFG’s Q1 profit weakened as underwriting and investments softened

The quarter tests the prior-year growth narrative: disciplined pricing and capital flexibility remain supports, but lower core earnings, weaker P&C underwriting and weaker alternative-investment performance temper the case. The supplied analysis does not establish a durable earnings-growth trajectory.

What drove AFG's -6.1% move after FY2025 Q1 earnings?

Research this report with FN2. Free to start; review your question before sending.

Reported After market closeNYSEFinancial Services $13.09B market cap
80quality score

Earnings scorecard

Reported versus consensus
Reported EPS — Consensus $2.17
EPS surprise — Reported versus consensus
Reported revenue — Consensus $1.74B
Revenue surprise — Reported versus consensus
Check the math in the surprise calculator >

Market reaction

event-close to next-session close
Stock move -6.1% Event window
SPY move +0.4% Same window
Abnormal move -6.6% Stock minus SPY
Volume 2.6× Versus trailing sessions
Subsequent drift +0.9% Up to 20 sessions
AFGSPY benchmark

Ask FN2 about AFG FY2025 Q1

Choose a question to continue your research

Free to start. Your question opens in chat for you to review and send. FN2 can look up the transcript, financials and prior quarters.

Transcript intelligence

What changed

Compared with the prior quarter’s strong 2024 results and confident tone, the Q1 analysis describes lower core net operating earnings, weaker P&C underwriting and alternative-investment performance, and a more cautious management tone. Guidance sentiment was maintained.

Guidance delta

The supplied analysis says guidance sentiment was maintained; it does not report a revised numerical outlook.

Key takeaways

  • Core net operating earnings fell to $1.81 per share, with weaker P&C underwriting and alternative-investment performance cited in the analysis.
  • The specialty P&C combined ratio was 94; California wildfire losses were below the upper range of expectations.
  • Shareholder returns exceeded $290 million through dividends and repurchases.
  • The Charleston Harbor sale was expected to contribute $1.20 per share to earnings, according to the supplied analysis.

Management priorities

  • Continue disciplined underwriting and pricing, including rate increases in commercial auto liability.
  • Consider strategic acquisitions and opportunistic investments using excess capital.
  • Maintain dividends and share repurchases, while pursuing the stated long-term alternative-investment return objective.

Follow AFG with an agent that reads every filing, transcript, and price print. Free to start.

Try FN2 free

Earnings History

Estimate Beat Miss Match
AFG REVENUE earnings history estimate and actual scatter chart 10 reported fiscal quarters and 4 future estimate-only quarters. Q4 '23 estimate $2B Q4 '23 actual $2B, beat Q1 '24 estimate $2B Q1 '24 actual $2B, beat Q2 '24 estimate $2B Q2 '24 actual $2B, beat Q3 '24 estimate $2B Q3 '24 actual $2B, beat Q2 '25 estimate $2B Q2 '25 actual $2B, beat Q3 '25 estimate $2B Q3 '25 actual $2B, beat Q4 '25 estimate $2B Q4 '25 actual $1B, miss Q1 '26 estimate $2B Q1 '26 actual $2B, miss Q2 '26 estimate $2B Q2 '26 actual $2B, beat Q3 '26 estimate $2B Q3 '26 actual $3B, beat Q4 '26 estimate $2B Q1 '27 estimate $2B Q2 '27 estimate $2B Q3 '27 estimate $3B
Show less

Analyst Consensus ?

ConsensusHold17 ratings
Bullish741.2%
Neutral1058.8%
Bearish00.0%

Analyst 52W Price Targets

$157.99Current
$135Low
$147.25Average
$165High

Latest persisted target per named analyst; persisted current price from FN2's market snapshot as of Nov 22, 2026. Not an FN2 forecast.

Firm-level rating actions

FMP grade actions identify the grading firm, not a named analyst.

FirmRatingPrior ratingActionDate
Keefe, Bruyette & Woods Market Perform Market PerformMaintainNov 9, 2026
Wells Fargo Overweight OverweightMaintainNov 5, 2026
Piper Sandler Neutral NeutralMaintainAug 10, 2026
Jefferies Hold HoldMaintainAug 11, 2025
BMO Capital Market Perform Market PerformMaintainNov 15, 2024
Show 12 more rating actions

Named analyst price targets

Upside is calculated against the persisted current price $157.99. FMP does not supply a rating on these named-analyst rows.

FirmAnalyst52W targetPrice when postedUpsideDate
OppenheimerAnalyst unavailable$150$157.24 -5.1%Nov 9, 2026
Piper SandlerAnalyst unavailable$156$145.59 -1.3%Aug 10, 2026
Piper SandlerAnalyst unavailable$140$136.69 -11.4%May 26, 2026
Wells FargoHristian Getsov$165$131.84 +4.4%Jan 15, 2026
JefferiesAndrew Andersen$142$142.25 -10.1%Nov 11, 2025
See 6 more

Track every rating change on AFG the moment it posts. Free to start.

Start free

Company context

Snapshot as of publication

American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) operates as an insurance holding company, specializing in providing a broad array of property and casualty insurance solutions across the United States. Its comprehensive product portfolio encompasses various lines of business, including property and transportation coverage, which offers protection for physical damage and liability concerning vehicles like buses and trucks, along with inland and ocean marine policies, agricultural-related products, and other commercial property and niche transportation insurance types.…

Historical context

All AFG earnings

Financial Services peers this season

Latest reports in the same sector

Latest beats and misses

Who reports next

Get the AFG recap when the next report posts

One email per quarter with the scorecard, the market reaction and what changed on the call. No account needed.

Sources

  1. Earnings call transcript and parsed analysis · 2026-05-11T10:29:34.698584+00:00
  2. FN2 earnings calendar · 2025-04-22T00:02:47.536505+00:00
  3. Polygon adjusted daily market bars · 2026-11-10T14:10:48.430876+00:00
  4. Financial Modeling Prep analyst price-target consensus and quote snapshot · 2026-11-10T14:10:48.428065+00:00

Methodology

Reported and consensus figures come from FN2's earnings event records. Market reaction and volume are calculated from daily adjusted bars around the event; abnormal move subtracts the SPY move over the same window.

Analyst target low, average, and high values are derived at request time from each named analyst's latest persisted FMP target. The current-price marker comes from FN2's persisted market snapshot. They are sell-side estimates, not an FN2 valuation or recommendation.

Transcript intelligence is a structured synthesis of the current and prior earnings-call analyses. Missing values stay missing and are never estimated.

By FN2 Research · Updated · As of 2026-11-10. For educational purposes only; not investment advice.